One of the clearest lessons emerging from our work with Meridian's inaugural cohort is that developing promising technology is one thing; building a successful defence technology business around it is quite another.
As we get further into the commercial and technical roadmaps of the ten companies, we're looking beyond what their technologies can do to understand what will make these businesses successful over the longer term. That includes how they establish a sustainable competitive advantage, particularly as artificial intelligence (AI) makes increasingly sophisticated software faster and less expensive to develop.
It also raises important questions about how emerging technology businesses should be valued when their products, markets and commercial models are still evolving. For founders, these considerations influence where they invest their time and capital. For investors, they are fundamental to assessing the potential of a business and the durability of its value.
The pace of change in AI is making both questions increasingly relevant, and they are becoming an important part of our conversations through Meridian.
AI is changing the technology moat
One of the recurring conversations we're having through Meridian concerns intellectual property and what makes a technology business defensible.
For many years, the ability to develop sophisticated software was itself a significant barrier to competition. Building a complex product could require substantial engineering resources, specialist expertise and years of development.
Those barriers haven't disappeared, particularly in highly specialised or demanding technical environments. But artificial intelligence is changing the equation.
Capabilities that might previously have taken a considerable amount of time and engineering effort to develop can increasingly be built much faster. The availability of powerful AI models, development tools and open-source technologies is making it easier for companies to create products that would once have required significantly greater resources.
The consequence is that some technology moats are becoming shallower, narrower and considerably shorter-lived.
I think this is particularly relevant to early-stage businesses, where the technology itself often represents a large proportion of the company's perceived value.
A founder may have developed something technically impressive, but the question increasingly becomes how long that achievement will remain difficult for somebody else to reproduce.
In some areas of software development, the relevant timeframe may no longer be two or three years. It could be two or three months.
That doesn't mean intellectual property is becoming irrelevant. It means we need to be more thoughtful about where genuine competitive advantage sits and how quickly that advantage might change.
In some businesses, it will continue to come from proprietary technology, algorithms or data that competitors cannot easily access or reproduce. In others, the more significant advantage may come from specialist knowledge, deep integration into customer environments, security credentials, distribution or established commercial relationships.
For defence technology companies, these distinctions are particularly important.
A software capability might be relatively straightforward to demonstrate in a controlled environment, but considerably more difficult to integrate into an operational system, validate against demanding requirements and deploy within a secure customer environment.
The technology is still important, but the ability to make it work reliably within the customer's operating environment can become a substantial part of the value.
This is something we're examining as we work through the cohort's technology and commercial roadmaps.
We're interested in understanding not only what each company has developed, but which elements of its capability are genuinely proprietary, what makes the product difficult to replicate and how that position might change as the wider technology landscape develops.
There is also a distinction between having a technological advantage today and building a business capable of maintaining that advantage.
A company may be first to demonstrate a particular application of AI, but being first does not necessarily mean it will remain ahead. If the underlying capability becomes more widely available, the business needs to have developed other reasons for customers to continue choosing its product.
Those reasons might include the quality of its proprietary data, the performance of its technology in specialist environments, its understanding of the customer problem or the difficulty of replacing a capability once it has been integrated into existing systems and workflows.
None of these advantages is automatic, and not every business will possess all of them.
But they are increasingly important considerations when assessing where a company's long-term value may come from.
I also think the speed of AI development creates an interesting tension for founders.
On one hand, it allows small teams to achieve considerably more with fewer resources. That is a significant advantage for emerging businesses competing against much larger organisations, particularly in a sector where the ability to develop and adapt capability quickly can be commercially and operationally valuable.
On the other, the same tools are available to potential competitors, which can reduce the time a company has to establish a sustainable position in its chosen market.
That creates a challenge around how founders allocate their resources. A business that spends too long perfecting a technology in isolation may find that the market has moved considerably by the time it is ready to commercialise it. Equally, a business that focuses entirely on speed of development without considering integration, customer relationships or long-term differentiation may struggle to defend its position once competitors emerge.
The opportunity to build has expanded, but so has the importance of establishing a commercial position alongside the technology.
For me, the central question is therefore not simply whether a business has developed something innovative, but what will continue to make it valuable as the technology around it evolves.
If somebody can reproduce a substantial part of your technical capability in three months, what will make your business difficult to compete with after those three months?
It's a question we're returning to through Meridian, and one I think every emerging technology business needs to consider as AI continues to change the pace of development.
Early-stage valuation is an art, not a science
Closely connected to the question of defensibility is another subject that has generated interesting conversations through the programme: how emerging technology businesses should be valued.
At an early stage, there is rarely enough information to pretend valuation is a precise science.
Revenue may be limited or non-existent, customer relationships may still be developing and the market itself may not yet be fully established. In some cases, the technology is being developed for applications where procurement and deployment can take considerable time.
That leaves founders and investors making judgements about what a business could become, rather than simply measuring what it has already achieved.
There is nothing inherently wrong with that. Investing in emerging technology has always involved assessing future potential.
But I think the pace of change in AI is making some of those judgements more complicated.
A company may have developed a capability that would have been exceptionally difficult to reproduce a few years ago. Today, the same underlying functionality might be achievable with a much smaller team and significantly less capital.
That doesn't necessarily make the original business less valuable, particularly if it has established customer relationships, proprietary data or a meaningful technical advantage. But it does challenge the assumption that the cost or difficulty of developing a product is necessarily a reliable indicator of what the business is worth.
This is where the relationship between technology defensibility and valuation becomes important.
Two businesses may have developed products that appear similarly sophisticated, but their long-term prospects could be very different.
One may depend heavily on capabilities that are becoming increasingly accessible through widely available AI models. Another may have developed proprietary technology, accumulated specialist data, established meaningful customer relationships or demonstrated that its product performs reliably in environments where competitors would struggle to operate.
The difference between those businesses may not be immediately obvious from a product demonstration.
Understanding it requires looking beyond the technology itself and examining the evidence supporting the company's competitive position.
For early-stage founders, there is also the question of how valuation influences the future development of the business.
Founders understandably want to retain as much ownership as possible and secure the strongest terms available when raising capital. But pushing valuation too far ahead of the evidence can create difficulties when the company next needs investment.
If the business hasn't demonstrated the progress implied by its previous valuation, the next funding round can become considerably more challenging.
This is particularly relevant in defence, where commercial progress may not follow the timescales founders initially anticipate.
A successful technical demonstration, a customer trial or a promising discussion with a potential buyer can represent meaningful progress, but each provides a different level of evidence about the company's commercial prospects.
There is a distinction between demonstrating that a technology works, demonstrating that a customer needs it and demonstrating that somebody is prepared and able to pay for it.
Each can support the investment case, but they shouldn't be treated as interchangeable.
One of the things we're exploring through Meridian is how companies can develop a clearer understanding of the evidence that supports their current position and the milestones that could justify greater value in the future.
That doesn't mean every business needs substantial revenue before it can attract investment. For some emerging technologies, the technical achievement, strategic relevance or quality of the team may provide a compelling investment proposition well before meaningful commercial income is generated.
But the assumptions behind that proposition need to be understood.
There is also another consideration that I think is sometimes overlooked when founders and investors focus too heavily on the valuation itself.
Successful early-stage investment depends on trust and shared motivation about the long-term journey, not simply agreement on what a business is worth today.
This is particularly important in defence technology, where the path to commercialisation can be unpredictable and where meaningful progress may not always translate immediately into revenue.
An investor needs to understand the realities of the market the company is entering, the milestones that will demonstrate progress and the possibility that the business may need to adapt its strategy as customer requirements become clearer.
Equally, founders need confidence that their investors understand what they are trying to build and are prepared to support the business through the challenges that inevitably arise.
That doesn't mean investors and founders will always agree. There will be difficult decisions, changes in direction and occasions when the interests of the two parties may not be perfectly aligned.
But if there is a shared understanding of what the business is trying to achieve, and a relationship built on trust and open communication, those challenges become considerably easier to navigate.
I think this is particularly important at the earliest stages of a company's development. The right investor can contribute much more than capital, just as the right founder can create value that extends well beyond the technology they have initially developed.
Ultimately, valuation establishes the terms of an investment, but the quality of the relationship between founders and investors can have a much greater influence on what happens afterwards.
What this means for Meridian and Defence Holdings
These two themes — technology defensibility and early-stage valuation — are closely connected to how we're approaching our work with the Meridian cohort.
We're not simply interested in whether a company has developed an impressive technology. We're interested in understanding what makes that technology valuable to a customer, how the business intends to establish a sustainable commercial position and what will enable it to grow.
That requires us to look at the business as a whole.
Through the programme, we're spending time with founders to understand their technical roadmaps, commercial strategies, customer relationships and funding requirements. We're also looking at the assumptions underpinning those plans and the evidence that will be needed to support the next stage of development.
In some cases, the priority may be strengthening the technology or demonstrating its performance in a particular operational environment. In others, it may be establishing a clearer route to market, developing relationships with potential customers or building the commercial evidence needed to support a future funding round.
The important point is that these considerations cannot be addressed entirely independently of one another.
A company's technology roadmap should reflect the requirements of the customers it intends to serve. Its commercial strategy needs to account for how quickly its competitive position might change. And its funding strategy should be built around the milestones that will create meaningful value, rather than simply the capital it believes it can raise.
This is also relevant to the development of Defence Holdings' Investment pillar.
Our approach is based on identifying emerging businesses where we believe there is a credible opportunity to create value, and where the wider Defence Holdings Operating Model can make a meaningful contribution to their development.
That contribution may involve capital, but it can also include commercial relationships, access to relevant expertise, support in understanding defence customer requirements and assistance in developing routes to market.
For us, the question is not simply whether a technology business represents an attractive investment today. It's whether we understand how that business can become more valuable over time, and whether Defence Holdings is well placed to help it achieve that.
Meridian gives us an opportunity to develop that understanding through sustained engagement with founders and their businesses, rather than relying solely on the information available at a particular point in an investment process.
That doesn't mean every business participating in Meridian will become an investment opportunity. The accelerator has its own objectives, and its value extends well beyond any potential investment relationship.
But the insights we're gaining are helping inform how we think about emerging technologies, commercial development and the characteristics of businesses that may be well suited to our wider ecosystem.
Looking ahead
If there's one conclusion I'd draw from these conversations, it's that the ability to develop sophisticated technology is becoming more accessible, but the challenge of building a successful technology business is not necessarily becoming any easier.
AI is creating extraordinary opportunities for small teams to develop capabilities that would previously have required considerably greater resources. At the same time, it is changing the assumptions around intellectual property, competitive advantage and the value investors should attach to technical achievement.
For founders, this makes it increasingly important to understand what will differentiate their businesses over the longer term, and to build commercial strategies that reflect how quickly the technology landscape is evolving.
For investors, it reinforces the importance of looking beyond the immediate capability and understanding the people, evidence, relationships and commercial position that sit behind it.
And for us at Defence Holdings, it reinforces why we believe there is value in working closely with emerging technology businesses, understanding the challenges they face and identifying where our experience and wider ecosystem can help them develop.
These are questions we'll continue to explore as Meridian progresses, and I expect our understanding will develop considerably as we work more closely with the ten companies in our inaugural cohort.
